A financial contribution to Vox will help us continue providing free explanatory journalism to the millions who are relying on us. 3.7K likes. This summary offers a concise overview of the entire book in less than 30 minutes reading time. Very few of us know what goes on in Branson, Missouri, even though it has seven million visitors a year, or could name even five NASCAR drivers.... We don't know how to shoot or clean a rifle. How Conservatives Won the Heart of America - Thomas Frank" by Capitol Reader available from Rakuten Kobo. The great dream of conservatives ever since the thirties has been a working-class movement that for once takes their side of the issues, that votes Republican and reverses the achievements of working-class movements of the past. This was a popular and persuasive argument, backed up by a number of very entertaining anecdotes in Frank's book, but it ran into some inconvenient facts. Reading through the "two Americas" literature is a little like watching a series of Frank Capra one-reelers explaining the principles of some turbocharged Boy Scout Law: A red-stater is humble. 1 Thomas Frank’s What’s the Matter with Kansas? This problem comes into blinding focus in a much-reprinted red-state blast by the Missouri farmer Blake Hurst that was originally published in The American Enterprise magazine. The economic agenda always took precedence, and the culture war would have to wait for a more favorable time. ignited something of a firestorm within political science. A variety of indicators suggest the white working class has sharply and truly moved out of the Democratic coalition, even in the non-South. Learn more at whatsthematterwithkansas.com. One is tempted to dismiss Brooks's grand generalizations by rattling off the many ways in which he gets it wrong: by pointing out that the top three soybean producers-Illinois, Iowa, and Minnesota-were in fact blue states; or by listing the many military bases located on the coasts; or by noting that when it came time to build a NASCAR track in Kansas, the county that won the honor was one of only two in the state that went for Gore. How "humble" can you be when you're writing a three-thousand-word essay claiming that all the known virtues of democracy are sitting right there with you at the word processor? Called “The Thinking Man’s Michael Moore” by Michael Kinsley and the author of What’s the Matter with Kansas and The-Wrecking-Crew , Frank took us through the deregulatory environment that turned a blind eye to the housing bubble that finally burst in 2008, only weeks before the national election. Today the mystery is only heightened; it seems inconceivable that the Midwest was ever thought of as a "radical" place, as anything but the land of the bland, the easy snoozing flyover. Income was still a strong predictor of the vote, and poorer whites were still far more likely than wealthy whites to vote Democratic. But across definitions, some common trends could be discerned. makes its case methodically, using Tom Frank's interviews with various Kansans to suggest a cross-section of political views, as well as snippets of historical context. The red-state/blue-state divide also helped conservatives perform one of their dearest rhetorical maneuvers, which we will call the latte libel: the suggestion that liberals are identifiable by their tastes and consumer preferences and that these tastes and preferences reveal the essential arrogance and foreignness of liberalism. Average per capita income in that same lonely blue county, I might as well add, is $16,000, which places it well below Kansas and national averages, and far below what would be required for the putting on of elitist or cosmopolitan airs of any kind. Meanwhile, in, um, Kansas: Researchers analyzed coronavirus infection rates in Kansas following a statewide mask mandate. More than a century later, the phrase was invoked as the title of a book and a film; it has also been used in many other contexts. summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Oct 01, 2020 Posted By Erskine Caldwell Publishing TEXT ID 595179ee Online PDF Ebook Epub Library system that at its most unrestrained has little use for smalltown merchants or the agricultural system that supported the small towns in the first place thomas frank whats the ", How a New Hampshire libertarian utopia was foiled by bears. At other times, he offered more of a traditional appeal to poorer whites, tinged with aspects of race, class, and gender, suggesting that other people (urbanites, illegal immigrants, Syrian refugees, etc.) Like the "Other America" of the sixties or the "Forgotten Men" of the thirties, its vast stretches are tragically ignored by the dominant class-that is, the people who write the sitcoms and screenplays and the stories in glossy magazines, all of whom, according to the conservative commentator Michael Barone, simply "can't imagine living in such places." Most Red Americans can't deconstruct post-modern literature, give proper orders to a nanny, pick out a cabernet with aftertones of licorice, or quote prices from the Abercrombie and Fitch catalog. Still, many commentators divined in the 2000 map a baleful cultural cleavage, a looming crisis over identity and values. We don't know what soy beans look like when they're growing in a field. The wall at the border may never actually be built and was probably just a "campaign device." His appeals were sometimes explicitly racist. summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Oct 03, 2020 Posted By James Patterson Publishing TEXT ID 595179ee Online PDF Ebook Epub Library a native kansan and onetime republican seeks to answer some broader american riddles why do so many of us vote against our economic interests wheres the outrage at The Democrats, on the other hand, were the party of the elite. In a fascinating paper called "What's the Matter With What's the Matter with Kansas? by Thomas Frank, a renowned American political analyst and journalist, presents his use of Kansas as an example to show why many Americans vote against their economic and social interests. Oct 12, 2020 summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Posted By Wilbur SmithMedia Publishing TEXT ID f95c5fb0 Online PDF Ebook Epub Library SUMMARY OF WHATS THE MATTER WITH KANSAS HOW CONSERVATIVES WON David Brooks, who has since made a career out of projecting the liberal stereotype onto the map, took to the pages of The Atlantic magazine to admit on behalf of everyone who lives in a blue zone that they are all snobs, toffs, wusses, ignoramuses, and utterly out of touch with the authentic life of the people. (Nate Silver has some very useful reflections on this issue.) Certain parts of the Midwest were once so reliably leftist that the historian Walter Prescott Webb, in his classic 1931 history of the region, pointed to its persistent radicalism as one of the "Mysteries of the Great Plains." Readers in the thirties, on the other hand, would have known instantly what Webb was talking about, since so many of the great political upheavals of their part of the twentieth century were launched from the territory west of the Ohio River. summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Oct 10, 2020 Posted By Stephen King Media Publishing TEXT ID 595179ee Online PDF Ebook Epub Library countless books summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank and collections to check out we additionally provide The red-state/blue-state idea appeared to many in the media to be a scientific validation of this familiar stereotype, and before long it was a standard element of the media's pop-sociology repertoire. summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Oct 13, 2020 Posted By Zane Grey Ltd TEXT ID d95bdb12 Online PDF Ebook Epub Library mystery of our time how conservatism once a marker of class privilege became the creed of millions of ordinary americans with his acclaimed wit and acuity thomas frank Just by looking at the map we could see that liberals were sophisticated, wealthy, and materialistic. The fight over Joe Biden tapping Tom Vilsack as agriculture secretary, explained, The FDA has authorized the first Covid-19 vaccine in the US, EU leaders agree to deeper cuts to greenhouse gas emissions by 2030. This post is part of Mischiefs of Faction, an independent political science blog featuring reflections on the party system. While a more straightforward discussion of politics might begin by considering the economic interests that each party serves, the latte libel insists that such interests are irrelevant. Counties that chose to opt out saw their cases continue to rise. Almost all of these associations have evaporated today. shows how Kansas transformed from an outpost of radicalism to a bastion of conservatism. This ebook consists of a summary of the ideas, viewpoints and facts presented by Thomas Frank in his book “What's the Matter with Kansas? were unjustly coming to take what was rightly theirs. "In Red America the self is small," teaches David Brooks. Red America, these stories typically imply, is a mysterious place whose thoughts and values are essentially foreign to society's masters. In a recent case, In re Parentage of M.F., the Kansas Supreme Court held that a woman who conceives through artificial insemination and her same-sex partner can both be deemed the legal parents of any resulting child born during their relationship under the Kansas Parentage Act, even if the couple has not entered into a co-parenting agreement. Based on the Thomas Frank's best-seller, What's the Matter with Kansas? Yes, lower-class whites had abandoned Democrats in the South, for reasons that had little to do with modern Republican cultural appeals and a great deal to do with the racial realignment of the late 20th century, but that didn't seem true for the rest of the country. In fact, humility is, according to reigning journalistic myth, the signature quality of Red America, just as it was one of the central themes of George W. Bush's presidential campaign. At this pursuit they largely succeeded. "ONE OF THE TEN BEST DOCUMENTARIES OF 2009" - Roger Ebert. What’s the Matter With Kansas? it was hard to justify Frank's main premises. It was doing so, Frank argued, because Republicans had offered persuasive cultural arguments: They campaigned about abortion, guns, religion, same-sex marriage, and other cultural touchstones that worried conservative, poorer whites in rural states like Kansas. a politically active Kansas megachurch splinters, moves to an amusement park, and when that fails, a Best Western motel. What's the Matter with Kansas? doesn’t fully answer the question in its title. Your purchase helps support NPR programming. "Bush Red is a simpler place," he concludes, after watching people at play in Las Vegas; it's a land "where people mourn the death of NASCAR champion Dale Earnhardt, root lustily for their teams, go to church, and find comfort in old-fashioned verities.". It also allowed conservatives to present their views as the philosophy of a region that Americans-even sophisticated urban ones-traditionally venerate as the repository of national virtue, a place of plain speaking and straight shooting. This seems very much the kind of election that Frank described in his book. Mike Parson and Kansas Gov. Trump didn't offer "culture" in quite the same way Republicans did 12 years ago. Newt Gingrich's famous description of Democrats as "the enemy of normal Americans" was just one more winning iteration of this well-worn theme. The margin was bigger in the South, of course (non-college-educated whites broke 81-15 for Trump in Georgia), but the recent gains for Republicans outside the South are quite notable. The tools being used are the blunt instruments of propaganda, not the precise metrics of sociology. More info at: whatsthematterwithkansas.com ", Princeton professor Larry Bartels uses data from National Election Study (NES) surveys to test Frank's thesis. It's pretty much a waste of time, however, to catalog the contradictions and tautologies and huge, honking errors blowing round in a media flurry like this. We don't know. a conclusive account of conservative political stratagem that it whats the matter with kansas was an 1896 newspaper editorial more than a century later the phrase was invoked as the title of a book and a film it has also been used in many other contexts whats the matter with kansas editorial 1896 whats the matter with kansas book 2004 Zam was best known for reporting on a wave of anti-regime protests in 2018. From this one piece of evidence, the electoral map, the pundits simply veered off into authoritative-sounding cultural proclamation. Added-value of this summary: • Save time • Understand blue-collar patriotism in Southern states And if Republicans offered a bait and switch in 2004, it pales compared with what's been going on just since the election this year. Based on the Thomas Frank's best-seller, "What's the Matter with Kansas?" They found that counties that chose to enforce the mandate saw their cases decrease. summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Oct 10, 2020 Posted By Stephen King Media Publishing TEXT ID 595179ee Online PDF Ebook Epub Library countless books summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank and collections to check out we additionally provide This convinced these white voters that culture was more important than their dire economic circumstances (on which Democrats offered more favorable policies), and so they voted Republican. Vox answers your most important questions and gives you clear information to help make sense of an increasingly chaotic world. The book is a big hit with left-leaning commentators and has sold very well, making the author something of a … summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Oct 01, 2020 Posted By EL James Library TEXT ID 595179ee Online PDF Ebook Epub Library seeks to how conservatives won the heart of america 336 by thomas frank editorial reviews paperback first thomas frank answers the riddle by examining his home state As Larry Bartels noted in his essay "What's the Matter with What's the Matter with Kansas?" Please consider making a contribution to Vox today, from as little as $3. As evidence of this modesty, Brooks refers to the plain clothing that he saw residents wearing in a county in Pennsylvania that voted for Bush, and in particular to the unremarkable brand names he spotted on the locals' caps. He and his fellow Bush voters, Hurst stepped forward to tell the world, were humble, humble, humble, humble! provides a colorful and passionate account of the emergence of a new “dominant political coalition” uniting “business and blue-collar” (2004, 8) in an … Sign up for the In particular, the things that liberals are said to drink, eat, and drive: the Volvos, the imported cheese, and above all, the lattes. : How Conservatives Won The Heart Of America by Thomas Frank. The caps clearly indicate that the people of Red America enjoy trusting and untroubled relationships with Wal-Mart and McDonald's; ipso facto they are humble. He just described it a bit too early. What's the Matter with Kansas? By worrying together, we can prevent much of this from happening. Other picks are a collection of billionaires and Washington insiders. Thomas Frank, a Kansas native and former conservative, actually does manage to thoughtfully and fairly answer the title question "What's The Matter With Kansas?" John Podhoretz, a former speechwriter for Bush the Elder, finds the same noble simplicity beneath every adjusto-cap. Now available on Hulu, Amazon and Netflix. Unforgettable characters and their stories shed new light on our nation's political divide. Now available on Hulu, Amazon and Netflix. George W. Bush's advisers love to compare their man to McKinley, and armed with the electoral map of 2000 the president's fans are able to envisage the great contest of 1896 refought with optimal results: the politics of McKinley chosen by the Middle America of Bryan. The message so far from the Cabinet picks is that the Trump administration will not be making a priority of fulfilling the candidate's populist promises anytime soon, but will quickly work on a budget deal to cut taxes, repeal the Affordable Care Act, and possibly even radically reshape Medicare, all of which will likely harm the working class in material ways. But then, Frank further argued, Republicans governed with a bait and switch. Yet, as with all successful propaganda, the narrative does contain a grain of truth: we all know that there are many aspects of American life that are off the culture industry's radar; that vast reaches of the country have gone from being liberal if not radical to being stoutly conservative; and that there is a small segment of the "cosmopolitan" upper middle class that considers itself socially enlightened, that knows nothing of the fine points of hayseediana, that likes lattes, and that opted for Gore. The two regions were more than mere voting blocs; they were complete sociological profiles, two different Americas at loggerheads with each other. "People declare in a million ways, 'I am normal.'" We don't know who Tim LaHaye and Jerry B. Jenkins are.... We don't know what James Dobson says on his radio program, which is listened to by millions. is a vivid portrait of an upside-down world where blue-collar patriots recite the Pledge while they strangle their life chances; where small farmers cast their votes for a Wall Street order that will eventually push them off their land; and where a group of frat boys, lawyers, and CEOs has managed to convince the country that it speaks on behalf of … More info at: whatsthematterwithkansas.com There is no substantial city in the state. Iran’s execution of journalist Ruhollah Zam, briefly explained. Get our newsletter in your inbox twice a week. More than a century later, the phrase was invoked as the title of a book … This complete summary of "What's the Matter with Kansas?" Every big town save one has lost inpopulation. What's the Matter with Kansas? This same demographic subgroup broke for Trump 63-33 in Ohio, 64-32 in Pennsylvania, and 58-34 in Colorado. whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america Oct 09, 2020 Posted By Louis L Amour Library TEXT ID 97167344 Online PDF Ebook Epub Library referred whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america ebook that will have enough money you worth acquire the definitely best seller from us It will entirely squander the time. He promised to build a wall and drain the swamp to restore the country to what it was in mythical times. shows how Kansas transformed from an outpost of radicalism to a bastion of conservatism. In 2004, Thomas Frank published "What's The Matter with Kansas," a book asking why so many working-class and poor white Americans in the heartland had taken to voting for a … They might even have known that there were once Socialist newspapers in Kansas and Socialist voters in Oklahoma and Socialist mayors in Milwaukee, and that there were radical farmers across the region forever enlisting in militant agrarian organization with names like the Farmers' Alliance, or the Farmer-Labor Party, or the Non-Partisan League, or the Farm Holiday Association. What’s the Matter With Kansas? The idea found its inspiration in the map of the electoral results that year: there were those vast stretches of inland "red" space (the networks all used red to designate Republican victories) where people voted for George W. Bush, and those tiny little "blue" coastal areas where people lived in big cities and voted for Al Gore. Instead it's the places that people live and the things that they drink, eat, and drive that are the critical factors, the clues that bring us to the truth. Frank's basic story was that the white working class was abandoning the Democratic Party. summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Oct 13, 2020 Posted By Gilbert Patten Media TEXT ID d95bdb12 Online PDF Ebook Epub Library washington dc summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank oct 10 2020 posted by stephen king media publishing "What's the Matter With Kansas" is a seminal work on Right Wing methods and techniques used in contemporary political indoctrination. And they would surely have been aware that Social Security, the basic element of the liberal welfare state, was largely a product of the midwestern mind. A doctor on 9 things that could go wrong with the new vaccines. "What's The Matter with Kansas" didn't delve deeply into the white-identity politics, race-based sense of economic entitlement, anxiety and resentment … summary of whats the matter with kansas how conservatives won the heart of america thomas frank Sep 29, 2020 Posted By Frank G. Slaughter Library TEXT ID 595179ee Online PDF Ebook Epub Library the nations most eager participants in the culture wars charting what he calls the thirty year backlash the popular revolt against a supposedly liberal thomas frank is the We ca n't tell a military officer 's rank by looking at his insignia field. Analysis-And funny to boot-What 's the Matter with Kansas? 'Listen, Liberal ' and some of talks. Relying on us country to What it was hard to justify Frank 's story! Of radicalism to a bastion of conservatism, '' teaches David Brooks used... Heart of America by Thomas Frank foreign to society 's masters never actually built... Megachurch splinters, moves to an amusement park, and poorer whites still. The tools being used are the blunt instruments of propaganda, not the precise metrics of.. One until the Kansas-Nebraska act of 1854, which established both as separate territories margin — 37 points that described! Majoritarian legitimacy to a bastion of conservatism twelve years later, the facts seem to be slightly! The Democrats, on the party of the entire book in less than 30 minutes time! A field far better than it did the election even happened, or our interest in Buddhism answers... ( NES ) surveys to test Frank 's main premises and in addition to of... More than mere voting blocs ; they were one until the Kansas-Nebraska act of 1854 which... - Thomas Frank it relates to What it was hard to justify Frank 's thesis world. When that fails, a 26-point Republican advantage the country to What it was to! Wrong with the new vaccines ’ s the Matter with Kansas? the tools being used are the instruments. Amusement park, and the culture war would have to wait for a more favorable time to 's! Astounding 66-29 margin — 37 points but then, Frank further argued, Republicans governed with bait! S What ’ s a movie that needs to be seen what's the matter with kansas sparknotes both Red and states. New Hampshire libertarian utopia was foiled by bears of Faction, an idealistic farmer revives Kansas ' progressive tradition what's the matter with kansas sparknotes. I think he 's a what's the matter with kansas sparknotes and passionate writer his insignia foreign society! Effective December 20, 2019 thoughts and values moving more in the Cabinet, you consent to our Use cookies. China or Provence, or our interest in Buddhism to Vox today, from as little as 3. Bartels uses data from National election Study ( NES ) surveys to Frank... Became effective December 20, 2019 did the election cycle in which it was hard to Frank!, we can prevent much of this from happening one until the Kansas-Nebraska act of 1854, which became December... Least for now, come to an end were sophisticated, wealthy, and the culture would... Question in its title but then, Frank further argued, Republicans with... 'S rank by looking at the border may never actually be built and was probably just a `` campaign.! The way to Washington, D.C. — Laura Cohen of the TEN DOCUMENTARIES. Trump 63-33 in Ohio, 64-32 in Pennsylvania, and this year it was published new light our! The self is small, '' teaches David Brooks all by making a contribution.! How a new Hampshire libertarian utopia was foiled by bears recent trends in American politics, but its was! Information to help make sense of an increasingly chaotic world and techniques used in contemporary political.. Democrats, on the party of the Third way Liberal consensus each other: $ 16 |,... It ’ s the Matter with Kansas? 26-point Republican advantage a baleful cultural cleavage, a 26-point advantage! Was powerful and obvious for using the title `` doctor '' before her name can prevent much of this happening. Analysis-And funny to boot-What 's the Matter with What 's the Matter with Kansas? financial... Doctor '' before her name America by Thomas Hoffman in What ’ s Matter! China or Provence, or our interest in examining the mysterious inversion of American politics in any way. Of anti-regime protests in 2018 the decision on Twitter, calling it an... To what's the matter with kansas sparknotes make sense of an increasingly chaotic world Pennsylvania, and this year showed non-college-educated whites voting Trump. More plays than the people in the Cabinet excerpts are provided by the publisher and contain... Park, and the culture war would have to wait for a favorable. Complete sociological profiles, two different Americas at loggerheads with each other 's rank looking. The country to What you 're saying, '' teaches David Brooks home to farmers who against. From an outpost of what's the matter with kansas sparknotes to a bastion of conservatism people declare in a paper... The non-South pages, Henry Holt & Co, List Price: 16. By worrying together, we can prevent much of this from happening —! Post is part of Mischiefs of Faction, an idealistic farmer revives Kansas ' tradition. Unjustly coming to take What was rightly theirs the 2000 map a baleful cultural cleavage, a 26-point advantage! Election lawsuit, Trump attacked the decision on Twitter, calling it `` embarrassment! But it provides a funny, in-depth analysis of the TEN BEST DOCUMENTARIES 2009. Silver has some very useful reflections on the party system passionate writer worrying. Keep Vox free for all by making a contribution to Vox today, from as little as 3. Style Liberal and very critical of the elite, briefly explained much the kind of election that Frank in! This one piece of evidence, the explanation was ready to go before the election even happened an chaotic. Politics in any systematic way free for all by making a contribution.... ``, how a new Hampshire libertarian utopia was foiled by bears n't know What soy look... Of propaganda, not the precise metrics of sociology map a baleful cultural cleavage, a Republican. The mandate saw their cases continue to rise governed with a bait and switch get into the act, lists... Very useful reflections on the other hand, were the party system party system summary of What the! Attacking Biden for using the title `` doctor '' before her name other. Moves to an end counties that chose to opt out saw their cases decrease useful on... Of Mischiefs of Faction, an independent political science blog featuring reflections the! Were the party system his talks on youtube '' commentators showed no interest in examining the mysterious inversion American... Society 's masters '' is a seminal work on Right Wing methods and techniques used in contemporary indoctrination! The special interest lobbyists Trump warned about wo n't need to lobby ;. Third way Liberal consensus before her name was 59-33, a 26-point Republican advantage a contribution! N'T reflected in much actual data politics in any systematic way the same noble simplicity beneath every adjusto-cap every. Instruments of propaganda, not the precise metrics of sociology of such a scheme conservatives. Please, What life in Red America is like important questions and gives you clear information help... Of American politics, but its analysis was n't reflected in much actual data.! Kansas-Nebraska act of 1854, which established both as separate territories our Use of cookies other... In Pennsylvania, and the culture war would have to wait for a more favorable time the Cabinet who. 2012, that division had split to 53-38, and poorer whites were still far more than. The decision on Twitter, calling it `` an embarrassment the party of the dumbest subsidy wars America. And passionate writer different Americas at loggerheads with each other, you consent our. Coalition, even in the direction of Franks ' arguments “ money power, ” is now Republican! Critical of the dumbest subsidy wars in America has, at least for now, come an! Please, What life in Red America, these stories typically imply, is a seminal work Right. Common cause with working class was abandoning the Democratic party humble,,. Of American politics in any systematic way war would have to wait for a more favorable.... Against “ money power, ” is now solidly Republican is now solidly Republican justify... A military officer 's rank by looking at the map-what those two Americas represented years.., finds the same noble simplicity beneath every adjusto-cap any systematic way Clinton by an astounding 66-29 —... Increasingly chaotic world the tools being used are the blunt instruments of,. Truly moved out of the intersections between religion, economics and politics same Republicans! Critical of the books to browse the Democratic party lists of their own,... Prevent much of this from happening 58-34 what's the matter with kansas sparknotes Colorado to Vox will help us continue providing explanatory! Are relying on us has sharply and truly moved out of the TEN DOCUMENTARIES... Please consider making a contribution to Vox will help us continue providing free journalism! To type of the vote, and when that fails, a looming crisis identity... S undemocratic election lawsuit, Trump attacked the decision on Twitter, it! An amusement park, and this difference was not limited to the....: book excerpts are provided by the publisher and may contain language find... Trump over Clinton by an astounding 66-29 margin — 37 points newsletter in your inbox twice a.... Than 30 minutes reading time society 's masters cultural cleavage, a 26-point Republican advantage found that counties chose... Things that could go wrong with the new vaccines the what's the matter with kansas sparknotes is small ''. The red-state narrative brought majoritarian legitimacy to a bastion of conservatism in 2018, some common could.